Monday, March 9, 2009

Ki Tissa 5769

In this week's parsha, we read about a few of my favorite things: hiking and Shabbat.

Ki Tissa has Moses climbing Mount Sinai not once, but twice. The first time, G-d calls Moses to the peak, where HaShem writes the tablets of the Covenant with his own finger. Apparently, HaShem doesn't write very quickly, because this takes 40 days. That's quite an expedition! While Moses is away from the Israelites' main camp, some shenanigans happen involving a golden calf. G-d, being all-seeing, noticed this and tells Moses that his people have been very naughty and deserve to be killed. Moses manages to talk HaShem out of wiping out the people and then heads home. When he gets there, he sees what G-d was talking about, and it makes him very angry, almost as angry as HaShem was. In his rage, Moses breaks the tablets. Which, naturally, means he has to hike his way back up Sinai to camp out with HaShem again for 40 more days. During this trip, Moses is given two shiny new tablets, a new commandment to keep Shabbat (as well as a few other special dates), and a radiant face.

There are a couple of things that are significant to me. While it appears in other places as well, in this parsha I really notice how Moses is closest to G-d at the top of the mountain. Here, the two of them talk. Really talk. As my rabbi has pointed out, their dialogue is almost like a married couple. It's very intimate, and I think very natural. As someone who loves to spend time out in nature, I certainly feel closest to HaShem after a nice, long, hike. And if that hike ends on the top of a mountain, so much the better. There's just something about looking down on the world and being able to see forever that makes you want to pray.

I also think that there's a good reason G-d gives the commandment for Shabbat on the mountaintop. I'm sure it's more significant to me, as a modern person, than it was to the ancients, because the only time I can typically climb a mountain is Shabbat. That's just the way life goes. But still, I think that the day most of us get the opportunity to really experience HaShem is Shabbat. For those of us who aren't Moses, we may never experience G-d the way he did on Sinai, but we can try.

The last part of the parsha that hits home for me is Moses's radiant face. He gets to see G-d's back, and he glows for the entire walk back to camp. That's something I can certainly identify with. While I've never seen HaShem, I've seen some pretty amazing and beautiful things, and they never fail to put an ear to ear grin on my face. That's how I picture Moses coming off the mountain that second time. Lit up from within, and eager to share his newest stories.

In my studies this week, the significance of the face stands out to me.  The parsha talks about two faces, those of G-d and Moses.

First, we have Moses asking to see HaShem's face.  He is told that no human can see the face of HaShem and live, so while Moses is protected by a cleft in a rock and shielded by HaShem's hand, HaShem walks past him and Moses is permitted to see G-d's back.  As The Five Books of Miriam points out, a frontal view of HaShem would not be possible, or even imaginable; G-d does not have a gender in egalitarian Judaism.

I hadn't really thought of that before.  As a kid, I pictured G-d as an old man with a long beard and flowing white robes, the "God the Father" of the Trinity.  Now that I'm older and my theology has evolved, I understand HaShem in a less literal way.  I haven't tried to picture HaShem in a long time, other than maybe as light or the series of Hebrew letters that you see on G-dcast.  I don't even know where to start, really.  HaShem is clearly anthropomorphic, based on the descriptions in this parsha and in Mishpatim a couple weeks ago.  Maybe HaShem looks a bit like an androgynous supermodel, tall and thin, with high cheekbones and no beard?

The Five Books of Miriam suggests that we look in the mirror to see HaShem's face; we are all created b'tzetlem Elohim.  HaShem should be recognizable within our own features.  The book also points out that once we can see G-d in our own faces, we should then recognize that the same is true for everybody we meet and treat them accordingly.

While I have always believed that it is important to treat my fellow human beings with dignity and respect, I don't always take the leap to appreciate that their faces are also the faces of G-d. It's kind of a lovely  thought, if a little Miss-America-wold-peace-ish.

The other face that is mentioned is that of Moses.  After he sees HaShem's back, his face becomes radiant. In listening to KOACH's podcast, I found a slightly different take on Moses' radiance than I previously had.

As Dr. Raymond B. Goldstein points out, it was not necessarily a good thing. The parsha says that people never looked at him the same way again; they became afraid of him. Moses started wearing a veil whenever he was outside the Tent of Meeting, because people were so disturbed by his face. Dr. Goldstein also notes, as I alluded to above, that people become radiant over various things, whether it's something they saw or experienced. Dr. Goldstein goes a step further. People aren't disturbed by people who glow over the birth of a new baby or winning a gold medal, but when Moses had a similar reaction to a spiritual experience, the people's reaction was very different. On the podcast, he wonders why this is.

I think it is because we can identify with more earthly reasons for radiance. We can share each other's joy over an accomplishment, because we understand it; we've been there and done that in our own lives. But most of us haven't had a powerful mystical experience like Moses did. We can barely comprehend that HaShem exists, much less deal with having seen what Moses saw. Since we don't understand it, we fear it; this is human nature.

Of course, there is still one problem with this. It does not explain how the veil prevents the Israelites from thinking Moses is strange. He's a grown man, and he's dressed like a woman. This started with my Rabbi and I riffing, but I think there really is something here. The two images my mind conjures up for the word "veil" are a bride and a burqa. These are very feminine images. I would think that the Israelites would make fun of him more because of this odd choice. There is one connection, though, that is intriguing. Earlier in the parsha, HaShem says that nobody can look on the face of G-d and refuses to show it to Moses. Shortly after that, Moses begins to hide his own face from view. Was Moses trying to be like HaShem?

Saturday, January 17, 2009

Shemot 5769

This has always been one of my favorite stories in the Bible - Moses's encounter with the burning bush. But, as much as I've loved reading it for years, this year I found a couple new points of view that give new depth, new meaning, and new ideas. You gotta love those podcasts.

The first one I heard was from G-dcast. The commentary came from Jason Lieberman, a man with cerebral palsy. It talked about how  Moses felt unable to perform the tasks HaShem was describing. I had honestly never considered it that way. I always thought he just felt that better candidates existed and wanted HaShem to pick someone else.

The other point Lieberman made that I had never thought about before was that HaShem could have erased any problems Moses had. Now that it's been pointed out, I don't know how I didn't see it before. The fact that HaShem simply gave Moses an accommodation and sent him on his way is very powerful. It shows that disabilities are  just challenges. It shows that we don't need superpowers to do HaShem's work. It also shows that we need to rely on each other. Where Moses was weak, Aaron was strong, and the two of them together were capable of more than either individual could ever accomplish.

The other podcast was Dvar Tzedek, from the American Jewish World Service, with commentary by Rachel Harcash (I may have this name wrong; I couldn't find it written, so I'm going with how it sounds). This does not appear in the podcast for Shemot, but rather, for Vaera. She also talks about how HaShem could have erased the impediment, but chose not to; however, she goes a slightly different way with it. She talks about how Moses had lived a life of privilege and had not been a slave. She also points out Aaron had experienced the exhausting work and the whips and the mind-numbing monotony of slavery. Her commentary raises the question: how could Moses speak for the people, when he had not experienced the injustices they suffered? By using Aaron as a translator, Moses's messages from HaShem would be colored by the collective experience.

I think this is a great question, and one I had never considered. For some reason, I had always had it in my head that Moses's speech impediment was a language barrier or a fluency problem that caused him to be difficult to understand. It seemed logical to me that he would have a hard time communicating with the Hebrews, if he'd learned to speak in the Palace. But this is a little different. The idea that Moses simply couldn't speak about the slavery experience, the idea that he felt unworthy to speak on behalf of those who were enslaved is fascinating. It's almost like he's saying that he'd feel inauthentic in that position. It also points out the difference between Moses and everybody else: he was the only one without the slave mentality. Perhaps that's the reason HaShem chose him; he had a mind that was open and capable of these ideas, while the others were somehow dulled by the endless work they had performed and the constant drain of persecution.  HaShem needed them both.

Sunday, January 6, 2008

Vaera, Exodus 6:2 - 9:35

Shabbat:  January 5, 2008/27 Tevet 5768

This portion begins with talks about the Israelites' suffering as Pharaoh's slaves in Egypt.  Moshe confronts Pharaoh for the first time, and their suffering increases because Pharaoh's heart is hardened against HaShem.  Since Pharaoh needs some convincing, the plagues are called down upon Egypt.  This portion covers the first seven.

I never noticed this before - 
"The first five plagues are accompanied by the passive formulation: 'then Pharaoh's heart was hardened,' because after they came upon him he refused to let the people go.  Accordingly, the Holy Blessed One said: 'Henceforth, even if he should want now to let them go, I shall not let him.'  For this reason, the text adds in the last five plagues, 'God hardened Pharaoh's heart.'"

This commentary builds on the themes that I'm working on in my own life right now: overcoming self-doubt.  I'm glad that I decided to start studying Torah; I hadn't planned on actually learning as much as I have.  Originally, I liked the idea that the first Torah portion for the book of Exodus coincided with my birthday, and I thought that it would be a good time to make a resolution to enhance my Judaic studies.  I anticipated a mostly academic experience, but in reality, it has been so much richer.  I really needed to carefully read the story of Moshe and apply the lessons he learned to my life.  So far, things have been, well, not easier, but at least I'm speaking up for myself and trying to improve my situation.  Before, I would have simply accepted it as beyond my control and been unhappy.
Best quote: "Moshe, despite his absolutely extraordinary life, is also just like all the rest of us: called by God to be a partner in the work of Redemption, called by a God who has faith in us even when we don't have faith in ourselves."

Sunday, December 30, 2007

Sh'mot, Exodus 1:1-6:1

Shabbat:  December 29, 2007/20 Tevet 5768

This is a great passage.  It covers the slavery in Egypt, the midwives' rebellion against Pharoh, and Moses' call to service.

I'm especially interested in it, because this was the Torah portion for my birthday.
I had originally planned to spend more time studying the portion, and then writing a hopefully decent essay about it.  I had also planned to continue doing this each week.  

So far, I feel I have fallen short, but...that's not unlike how Moses felt when he was chosen to lead the Hebrews.
He believed that he wasn't good enough; he thought that HaShem should have chosen someone who was a better speaker, who was more charismatic, who was, well, not Moses.  But, as we know, he was convinced otherwise by certain miracles.  This is where we're very different; I don't have a staff, much less one that was turned into a snake before my eyes. 

Even so, there are some important things that I need to learn as I begin my 28th year:
  • Speak up for myself, when the situation calls for it
  • Correct injustices happening around me
  • Believe that I am capable of more than I know now